My Friends

Arrow Up

Arrow Up
Arrow Down
,
  • Fri
    25
  • Sat
    26
  • Sun
    27
  • Mon
    28
  • Tue
    29
  • Wed
    30
  • Thu
    31
GIRLS GIRLS GIRLS Jul 25, 2014 New mixed-media works from local artists Jaclyn Rose and Carly Ealey, which explores the trials and tribulations of womanhood in this strange new world. 84 other events on Friday, July 25
 
News
San Diego planning director’s uphill battle to create walkable communities
Film
Documentary about the famous film critic leads our rundown of movies screening around town
Urban Scout
Barry Bell and Mark Quint peddle strange and wonderful stuff at their occasional sales
Seen Local
Painter spends plenty of time curating and exhibiting interesting work online
Editorial
Kevin Faulconer should follow Dallas County Judge Clay Jenkins’ lead

 

 
Log in to use your Facebook account with
San Diego CityBeat

Login With Facebook Account

Recent Activity on San Diego CityBeat
 
Home / Blogs / Last Blog on Earth
. . . .
Thursday, May 31, 2012 - Last Blog on Earth | News

Dumanis accepted donation from doctor she previously prosecuted

Donor copped a plea to domestic violence and prescription drug charges in 2009

By Dave Maass
DA-Bonnie-Dumanis Bonnie Dumanis

From the very inception of District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis' mayoral campaign, the Republican candidate has bragged about garnering endorsements from both sides of the political aisle. But Dumanis has also picked up support from both sides of the courtroom, and we' re not just talking about her questionable endorsement from San Diego County Public Defender Henry Coker. 

According to campaign-finance disclosures, Dumanis also cashed a campaign check from a Lasik surgeon she prosecuted a little more than three years ago on domestic-violence and prescription-drug charges. 

In March, Dr. Manoj Motwani, who runs the Motwani Lasik Institute, donated $150 to Dumanis' candidacy. According news reports from the time, Motwani was accused of beating his girlfriend while driving on Interstate 5 in October 2007 and was arrested in April 2008 by the California Highway Patrol. He was also accused of receiving prescriptions under false pretenses. 

Motwani proclaimed his innocence, even going so far as to employ a PR firm to promote his side of the story. In the interest of full disclosure: Motwani hired J.Walcher Communications, whose principal is in a relationship with CityBeat editor David Rolland. Walcher filed a complaint against Motwani in small-claims court over unpaid bills, but the firm was not the source of this story. 

Motwani pleaded guilty to misdemeanor charges in January 2009, as well as an unrelated drunk-driving charge. He was sentenced to three years or probation and a year-long domestic-violence course and ordered to donate $8,000 to a battered-women shelter.   

We spoke with Motwani's assistant, who said she would pass on a message and forward our email to Motwani. He has not responded. Dumanis' campaign and office has not replied to questions about how she balances her tough-on-crime credentials against her acceptance of support from someone she prosecuted. 

CityBeat identified several other donors whose names match defendants in criminal cases, but Dumanis did not confirm whether these were, in fact, the same individuals. 

Ida Bleich, a pharmacist who donated $200 to Dumanis in October, also came into contact with the District Attorney's office when she was suspected of leaving threatening phone messages on a coworker's voice mail. The case was dismissed early on when a judge found the messages sounded nothing like Bleich and there was no phone records of making the call. The District Attorney's office wrote in a memo that it did not intend to refile charges due to weakness of the evidence. 

 
 
Close
Close
Close