My Friends

Arrow Up

Arrow Up
Arrow Down
,
  • Wed
    16
  • Thu
    17
  • Fri
    18
  • Sat
    19
  • Sun
    20
  • Mon
    21
  • Tue
    22
Soweto Gospel Choir Apr 16, 2014 Singing in English as well as a number of South African languages, the two-time Grammy Award-winning choir fuses traditional African gospel music—complete with occasional clicks and bird songs—with Western songs of celebration. 55 other events on Wednesday, April 16
 
Canvassed | Art & culture
A tale of near-death, bloody steaks and unprecedented opulence
Canvassed | Art & culture
Redwood Media Group acquires the annual event
News
Why the city can’t maintain enough emergency trucks
Editor's Note
I don’t really go for the caged-wildlife thing to begin with

 

 
Log in to use your Facebook account with
San Diego CityBeat

Login With Facebook Account

Recent Activity on San Diego CityBeat
 
Home / Articles / News / News /  County makes a disaster of the Brown Act
. . . .
Wednesday, Jun 27, 2012

County makes a disaster of the Brown Act

Unified Disaster Council meeting turns into a brief battle over open government

By Dave Maass

The local region’s disaster-response plan is a beast of a document, comprising 17 sections, or annexes, lettered A through R, with Annex N weirdly left “unassigned.” How the county will communicate with the press in an emergency is detailed in Annex L, which covers public information and “rumor control.”

The strategy is guided by two policies: that the public has a right to know and that the news media’s job is to disseminate accurate information and the press should therefore be “treated with the respect warranted by that role.”

While that may apply to tsunamis, earthquakes, influenza outbreaks and terrorist attacks, the County of San Diego hasn’t quite learned how to respect the public and media in day-to-day planning.

The Unified Disaster Council is the regional governing body for emergency response. Made up of representatives from 18 jurisdictions and staffed by county employees, the UDC meets in even-numbered months in an earthquake-proof, secure compound off Ruffin Road.

CityBeat attended the Thursday, June 21, meeting for an upcoming story. As is typical with government meetings, a stack of agendas and minutes were available near the door, but missing were copies of the handouts corresponding to the items on the agenda. Instead, there was a single manila folder containing a single copy of everything.

As UDC began discussing its $3.8-million budget, we began flipping through the folder. Suddenly, Sarah Gordon, the communications officer assigned to public safety, stormed in and took it. We asked for copies of the budget being discussed. She said no.

David Greene, a lawyer with the First Amendment Coalition, says this was a textbook violation of California’s open-government laws.

“It’s both a Brown Act and a Public Records Act violation,” Green says. “Any document distributed to all or a majority of members of a board before or during a meeting must be made public ‘without delay’…. Normally we don’t allow agencies to pass budgets in secrecy.”

The Ralph M. Brown Act was passed in 1953 to protect the public’s right to attend and speak at government meetings. The district attorney has the authority to investigate Brown Act violations, and private citizens can sue to invalidate decisions made during meetings that failed to comply with the law.

Gordon says the folder was meant for someone else, and she didn’t know whether the records were public. After we put up a fuss over email and Twitter, citing multiple legal resources on the matter, Gordon produced the documents—six hours after the meeting ended.

Now, if only we can find out what happened to Annex N.


Email davem@sdcitybeat.com or follow him on Twitter @DaveMaass.




 
 
 
 
 
 
Close
Close
Close